cedatopic
Friday, June 02, 2006
  An alternative areas resolution - equal protection
An alternative areas resolution -- Equal Protection (I wrote about this on the blog - see my very first blog post)

The resolution would say:

The United States Supreme Court should strengthen the constitutional protection against race discrimination by overruling one of its decisions which held that a government action/law/statute did not violate the equal protection clause of the 14th amendment.
Cases would include: Milliken v. Bradley (school desegregation), Washington v. Davis (held that policy with disparate impact on blacks was not unconstitutional without evidence of discriminatory intent), Gratz (affirmative action), Shaw v. Reno (racial gerrymandering),, Palmer v. Thompson (holding that city's decision to close all public swimming pools rather than integrate them did not violate the Equal Protection Clause because the city closed all swimming pools "equally").

This topic would be great and you are already familiar with most of the key cases because they tend to be the "landmark" cases in constitutional law. And this would appease the fear that a bunch of list resolutions plus one areas resolution (1st amendment) would inevitably result in a 1st amendment topic.
 
Comments:
you can limit this to employment, education, and political gerrymandering, and it will be even more limited, like the 1A resolution
 
Post a Comment



<< Home
a blog dedicated to writing the ceda debate topic
TOPIC PAPERS
  • 2006 Supreme Court Interim - Galloway
  • 2006 "Overrule" - Smelko
  • 2004 SC Federalism - Galloway
  • 2003 Supreme Court - Galloway

  • 2006 Abortion - Lee
  • 2006 First Amendment - Patrice
  • 2006 Right-to-Die - Moore
  • 2006 Plenary Power - Harrison
  • 2006 Ripeness - Neal
  • 2006 Aff Action - Hall
  • 2006 Pres Powers via Courts - Stables
  • 2006 Updated War Powers - Stables
  • 2006 Morrison - Galloway
  • 2006 Milliken - Mancuso
  • 2006 Religious Freedom - T. O'Donnell
  • 2006 Strike Exec on 1A - Mahoney
  • 2006 1A vs. Ntl Sec Supp - Mahoney
  • 2006 1A vs. Ntl - Day 3 - Mahoney
  • 2006 Glucksberg - Helwich
  • 2006 Hudnut - Galloway
  • 2006 Gregg - Stables
  • 2006 Fundamental Rights - Vats
  • 2006 Terry Aff evidence - Bauschard
  • 2006 Terry Neg evidence - Bauschard
  • 2006 Terry Blocks - Bauschard
  • 2006 Terry Thoughts - Zive
  • 2006 Garcetti - O'Donnell
  • 2006 - Fundamental Rights - Vats
  • 2006 Case List Survey - Mancuso
  • 2006 Executive Authority - Stables
  • 2006 Detention - Bauschard
  • 2005 Immigration - Peterson
  • 2005 Democracy Promotion - Stables

  • TOPIC RESOURCES
  • Supreme Court Website
  • Guide to US Supreme Court Research
  • Supreme Court Rules
  • FindLaw: Cases and Codes
  • FindLaw: Special Coverage: War on Terrorism
  • Jurist: Legal News and Research
  • The Curiae Project/Yale: SC Records/Briefs
  • The Supreme Court Monitor
  • The Oyez Project: Multimedia
  • C-SPAN: Judiciary Resources
  • American Constitution Society Blogs
  • ACLU: Supreme Court Page
  • The Rutherford Institute

  • 2007-08 TOPICS
  • US Policy Toward Genocide
  • US Policy Toward Latin America
  • Global Poverty and Disease
  • Military/Troop Reforms
  • Latin America

  • TOPIC PROCESS
  • Topic Process Report 2006
  • CEDA Constitution

  • COMMITTEE MEMBERS
  • Gordon Stables, At-Large Rep, Chair
  • Darren Elliott, CEDA EC Rep
  • Ryan Galloway, At-Large Rep
  • Malcolm Gordon, Student Rep
  • Ed Lee, At-Large Rep
  • Steve Mancuso, NDT Rep,
  • Joe Patrice, CEDA EC Rep
  • Dave Steinberg, CEDA EC Rep
  • Kelly Young, ADA Rep


  • ARCHIVES
    2006-05-07 / 2006-05-14 / 2006-05-21 / 2006-05-28 / 2006-06-04 /


    Powered by Blogger